UC Davis study finds that greatest predictor of farmworker use of Medicaid is having children.
By Karen Finney, UC Davis
Undocumented farmworkers are half as likely as those who are documented to use Medicaid, the federal health insurance program available to low-income individuals and families, according to a new study from UC Davis Health System. The research also shows that the greatest predictor of farmworker use of Medicaid, which provides coverage for prenatal, pediatric and emergency care regardless of documentation status, was having children.
“Undocumented agricultural workers are using Medicaid at about half the rate of documented immigrants and citizens, and they appear to be using it in accordance with the law,” said J. Paul Leigh, senior author of the study, professor of public health sciences and researcher with the Center for Healthcare Policy and Research. “There’s a perception that undocumented farmworkers are overusing Medicaid resources, but our findings indicate the opposite.”
In conducting the study, which is published online in the Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, Leigh analyzed records from the U.S. Department of Labor’s National Agricultural Workers Survey (NAWS) on 41,324 farmworkers from 1993 through 2009, about half of whom were migrants working without residency, citizenship or visas.
Because the NAWS database is the only nationally representative sample of undocumented workers, it is a rare source of information on demographics and income at both individual and household levels for this often elusive group. Given that almost 50 percent of Medicaid recipients are children, the data on households rather than individual adults was particularly relevant to the current study.
Leigh found that undocumented farmworker heads of household were 52 percent less likely to use Medicaid than their documented counterparts: 22.6 percent of documented farmworker heads of household and only 12.2 percent of undocumented farmworker heads of household reported that one or more family members received Medicaid services over two-year intervals during the 16-year study period.
The odds of receiving Medicaid benefits for documented heads of household with one child were 6.57 times greater than that of documented heads of household with no children. One-child undocumented heads of household were 8.4 times more likely to utilize Medicaid than childless documented heads of household.
“Simply having children is the best determinant of Medicaid use,” said Leigh. “Use by undocumented, unmarried males appears to be extremely rare.”
The seemingly disproportionate effect of children on undocumented versus documented heads of household may be explained by access to non-government health insurance options, according to Leigh. Documented workers are much more likely than undocumented workers to have employer-sponsored health insurance, which families typically prefer over Medicaid. Undocumented heads of household, even those with children who are U.S. citizens, rarely have that choice.
“Undocumented workers don’t have any other place to go for health insurance,” Leigh said. “As soon as they have a child in the family, undocumented workers are much more likely to use Medicaid.”
Higher income, either for individuals or families, was associated with lower odds of Medicaid use for both documented and undocumented heads of household. There were also variations by region, with California having the highest odds of Medicaid use.
This is one in a series of studies of health care utilization prepared by Leigh, an expert in economics and occupational illnesses. Next in the pipeline is a study of those who use food stamps and the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants and Children, which provides supplemental foods, health care referrals, and nutrition education for low-income women and young children who are deemed at nutritional risk.
“Medicaid Use by Documented and Undocumented Farm Workers” was co-authored by Yoon-Kyung Chung of the Korea Energy Economics Institute in Seoul and Ph.D. graduate of the UC Davis Department of Economics. It was supported by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (grant number 2U54OH007550-11). The study is available online.